This bad boy doesn't have a review? Well lets remedy that!

This is one of those skill cards that tick the boxes for good skill cards. "This skill card gives a numerical bonus on a test and":

• Furthers the board state.
• Improves my character state.

Generally cards that don't tick the boxes above tend not to be quite as good as the rest. For example the reason many many decks choose Guts is because it has a high change at "healing" damage or horror, as well as gaining you a card.

Deduction ticks the former box, "Furthers board state". You gain 2 clues from a location for 1 action, taking you 1 step closer to the endgoal, not to mention that it helps you get the original clue with it's +1. Action compression is one of the most useful mechanics a card can grant, Deduction does this all for free, making it one of the best skills in the game and a go-to card to fill out the deck of anybody who can bring it in-faction, whether you're Joe Diamond or Daisy Walker.

Note that the card is a drastically weaker pick in solo, due to the prevalence of single clue locations, but in this case it is still a great card as a means to finish 2-clue spots more easily, especially if its a big 3+ shroud victory location, definitely still worth a slot..

Terrible. Why?

• Enemies can still spawn on you.
• An elite breaks it, more common than it might seem.
• Action and card for circumstantial benefit.
• You don't stay at many locations for long enough to warrant a card like this.

There are some combo mechanics, In the Know and Connect the Dots for example, still the benefit is extremely limited in scope. The levelup version Barricade is vastly better but again the benefit is so transient that the XP commitment and card slot will just feel that much worse when you have this card in hand unable to leverage it into a useful gameplay benefit.

Personally I think the barricade should have resources on it, and resist so-and-so many attempts to move or spawn into a location, and allow the player to leave instead, but this is not so and thus this remains a terrible card to include in pretty much any deck.

I just realized that this card has Victory 0 on the bottom. I guess that means that this effect only happens once, since the card won't ever shuffle back into the Encounter deck? I think we totally missed that when we played this Scenario in the Return To Dunwich.

This is a pretty good card. However, I think Seeker investigators with high might sometimes want to pass on this card to include cards that are more urgently needed.

Getting one free testless clue is amazing. However, this card is in a faction that will often have the best chance of testing for clues, so it's providing a one-time solution to a problem that Seeker investigators can regularly solve anyway.

In my opinion, it is better for Seeker investigators to build an engine to consistently get clues rather than playing one-off cards to get clues every so often (Cards like Dr. Milan Christopher, Magnifying Glass, etc.). When you can usually spend one action to get at least one clue, spending 2 resources and a card to get a clue is a little less enticing.

Roland Banks really likes this card, especially if he is on his own. He often wants to focus on playing cards that support fighting, since he can use fighting as an alternative means to get clues, but this card lets him get a clue even when no enemy is around. He particularly likes using this to crack high-shroud locations which would usually give him some trouble with his base of 3.

I think one of the best uses of this card is in Joe Diamond's hunch deck. Because it's fast and the 2 resource cost is discounted to 0, it's essentially free, and it's easy to play because there's normally a clue around to pick up somewhere.

I think this is a good card. As I said before, a fast, testless clue is almost always welcome. I think that most clue-finding focused investigators may pass on this card to make room for other options, but I think other investigators should give it consideration.

The 2 reasons this card is surprisingly bad (OK, OK at least not as good as first expected) are the same reasons that Bandolier is surprisingly good:

1. Two handed weapons make you forgo lots of great non-disposable assets like Machete and Magnifying Glass, among others.
2. Then, once the mighty Flamethrower is in play, a steady stream of mediocre enemies will make you debate whether to conserve your ammo and use your fists, or waste an ammo.

So how do we get around this and take advantage of the unmatched combat potential of the Flamethrower? As of this review, there is no way around the first problem so you’ll just have to build around the slot-hungry flamethrower. The best way to get around the second problem is to have alternative combat cards outside of hand and body slots. Best at this strategy is Zoey Samaras, who has her Zoey's Cross as well as access to Shrivelling and Mists of R'lyeh. Taunt is a nice addition to ensure all of the enemies are in range of the thrower’s blast.